Tuesday, March 24, 2015

Marketing is a "necessary evil"

In many organizations (clearly excepting the major brand powerhouses like P&G) the marketing function is perceived as a “necessary evil.”

A popular saying illustrating how difficult it is to quantify the return on advertising is attributed to John Wanamaker: "Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is I don't know which half.

The Wanamaker quote is illustrative of general feelings about marketing to most people running a business.  Here I refer to those that are responsible for making a profit and being accountable to the shareholders.  They are often perplexed as to what marketing does – but know that without it they will be absent from their competitors in the marketplace.  Every dime they spend on marketing that does not have a connection to sales puts it into the “investment” category.

The investment category is a much easier category to tolerate when there are profits and a rising revenue curve to cover “investments.”  Everyone is happy when the company is making money.  The pressure comes when revenue and profits are down and scrutiny becomes the watchword in the C-Suite.  This is when the “necessary evil” comes under fire and often does not survive the skirmish due to a lack of ammunition. 

You need a framework and relationship between the marketing function and the C-Suite that recognizes this potential conflict and resolves it upfront by building in metrics that allow for comparison to alternative investments.


Monday, March 23, 2015

Marketers speak a different language than business people

In my last post I discussed how we have a basic language problem between marketers and the C-Suite.  Following this line of thought, it then becomes vitally important that this communication is in the “language” they understand – not the language we use. 

The best analogy that I can think of is that marketers speak French and business people speak English.

Think about French as a language.  French is sexy.  It has a mystique.  It flows and sounds like music – even when it is used to insult you!  From a French person’s perspective, there’s nothing special about the language, it’s simply how they communicate.  But alas, while French is such a wonderful language it doesn’t help you much when traveling the rest of the world.  Not that many people speak French – in fact, it’s not a language of commerce as it once was.  

Consider the following scenario.  Proud that you’ve completed the latest level of duolingo, you fly from France to London and order your croissant and coffee only to experience the wait staff looking at you like you’re speaking Spanish! You’re not “one of them.”  You speak “funny.”  You sound like you’re TRYING to speak their language but the nuances are lacking, you’re a muffled little warbler trying to speak to the eagles.  Ironically, the same would happen in reverse if a native-English speaking person flew from London to France – only probably more exaggerated due to the cultural differences between those two nations. 

You are not speaking the language of commerce – metaphorically English – literally Finance!  You must obtain at a minimum a “tourist level” vocabulary of this very important language.  Finance is what they speak in the C-Suite.  Finance is what they live in the C-Suite.  Finance is the only language investors and Wall Street REALLY understands.  Finance is what drives decision-making within companies and ultimately justifies both salaries and bonuses in the C-Suite!

Have I mentioned that you need to be able to speak Finance as part of your business acumen in order to address the C-Suite!


Friday, March 20, 2015

Speaking in terms the C-Suite can understand - and relevance of marketing spend to overall budget

The logical connection then between the marketing function and senior management is that we marketers must communicate our successes to the “C-Suite” in a way that they will understand.  We cannot rely on our own metrics and peculiar language (think about when you were new to marketing and first heard the term GRPs – that term doesn’t exist outside the media and marketing world).  Senior managers often do not understand the connection between page views and sales.  They certainly don’t make see the direct correlation between sports sponsorships and business performance.   We have a “language” problem.  We are like a dog that drags in a dead bird and wildly wags her tail at their superior performance of finding the dead bird (that stinks to high heaven – which makes it EVEN BETTER) and dropping off as a gift of great import – an homage – to its owner.  In the dog world, we hit a home run and are up for a CLIO award!  But the owner only sees a stinking dead bird that is ruining their day.  All they want from the dog is love and probably some sense of security for their residence.  We have to learn to speak in terms of the senior managers.  Terms that do not include GRPs!


Side note: In most large companies, marketing activities represent about 10% of the overall operating budget.  It is significant in itself, but in the total big picture it is only 10% of the budget.  Worse than that, it is one of the few that is often perceived of as pure cost and not directly connected to profit.  Marketing has the same persona as Human Resources – or Finance – got to have it but really hate paying for it!  Marketers tend to be ethno-centric and assume the rest of the world is as interested in marketing as they are – and they are not – they are interested in their world – the world of the 90%!

Thursday, March 19, 2015

World-class marketing campaigns aren't enough anymore!

World-class marketing campaigns aren’t enough anymore.  In the past, a marketer could “wow” the senior management of their company with amazing creative work that was totally on message.  Whether it was a commercial, a print ad, a banner ad, an out-of-home board, etc., it was magical to the executives.  Marketers had a certain panache, an aura of understanding that was almost zen-like in its appearance.  Nobody was sure why certain things were “successful” from the marketing department, but you could look at the output and judge for yourself whether it touched your sense of direction or not. 

However, the landscape of the company management world has definitely changed.  What was a recognizable forest in the past is now a completely open plain.  Everything is exposed.  Social media, emails, web-reporting, to name a few, now highlight marketing investments that in the past were easy to keep from public scrutiny.  Today’s leaders are as concerned about a potential social media viral storm as they are of a hostile takeover.

Enter the age of marketing accountability.  It’s been coming on the horizon for a long time – and its now here.  If a senior manager cannot prove to his/her constituents that an investment has a return (more sales, more anything!), they are literally taking risks with their careers.  People do not become senior managers by taking risk – they rise on the tide of others taking risk and staying just far away enough from it to keep from being burned.  They enter the picture when the fire is gone and there are rewards to be reaped. 


So that great commercial or creative ad of the past, while still very important for a number of reasons, cannot stand as the sole justification of the large investments involved.  The senior managers need something to explain why they did it – and what the benefits or returns on that investment produced.

Friday, March 6, 2015

What Every CEO Would Tell A Sports Marketer (If They Would Listen)

What Every CEO Would Tell A Sports Marketer (If They Would Listen)

First, understand MY world.  I am in charge of an entire enterprise – and marketing typically makes up about 10% of my entire expense budget.  Sponsorships typically make up 10% of that 10% budget – or 1% of my entire budget.  I’ve got much bigger fish to fry before I get to my 1% sponsorship budget line item – people costs, facilities cost, raw materials, finished goods, etc., to name a few of the biggies.  While sponsorships are high profile – in some cases too high for my comfort – I would prefer that they were like great children – seen and not heard!

So given that you’re 1% of my budget and probably a fraction of my management headaches given my prime responsibility to increase shareholder wealth, I would offer you the following advice:

1.     Stay out of the press – period.  I’m not talking about leveraging our big investments in the sponsorships we have or are considering – that’s one of the main goals from what I can tell.  Let the sponsored properties talk for us with our concurrence and guidance.  But please don’t put us in the spotlight – it will only lead to more tough questions for me regarding how we are spending our hard-earned money!
2.     Please figure out how to measure what we are getting out of these relationships.  While you’re just 1% of my budget, you can become 100% of my time if a board member or press article brings an investment under scrutiny.  When that happens, and it will happen, give me the ammunition to defend what a great investment these sponsorships have been for us.  Do not wait until I need the data to go try and find it – or even worse, invent it.  You should be the manager and have this knowledge on the tip of your tongue at all times.
3.     Find a way to make these investments valuable to every part of our business.  Please don’t make it only about signage or seats at some venue.  We have a diversified business with business-to-consumer needs and business-to-business needs.  We have to squeeze out every bit of value for all of our businesses – not just our consumer-facing businesses or just our client/partner business.  As you add value, track and report it (see number 2 above!).
4.     Make our investments relevant and important to our employees/associates.  Make out people proud of our investments by involving them and rewarding them for working so hard for us. If this is perceived as the exclusive domain of our senior managers, it will only create divisiveness and dissention.
5.     Open new doors for us with the other sponsors. We have a common point of interest, and probably share at least some brand values. Make introductions for our sales team, and track where it goes, using numbers that matter to me. I’m not talking cocktail parties, I’m talking business meetings (see number 2 above, again!).
6.     Please tell me that our social media team is all over this sponsorship, as a vehicle for driving consumer (and employee) engagement. I may not understand the value of social media to us quite yet, but I want to make sure we are playing in this space as a hedge against future value.
7.     Improve the performance of our sponsorships every year. Any program, no matter how good, can get stale over time. Pare the under-performing components, and use those savings to try something new that can be readily measured. Then shift resources for the best returns. This is smart management. You won’t regret taking reasonable risks if there is solid business rationale behind them.
8.     Challenge our sacred cows. Don’t be afraid to tell me that our biggest sponsorship investment has stopped delivering results or is on a downward trajectory. This just might be the perfect time for a major shift in sponsorship strategy. If not, we need to find a way to get our current relationships back on track. These are big decisions and can’t be made overnight. I need an early heads-up.
9.     Keep an up-to-date risk assessment of all of our relationships. If one of them begins to cross from “green” to “yellow,” I want to know well before we see “red.”
10. Always deliver to me any “cut roses!”  Once the roses are cut, they will bloom very quickly and then start to die.  This my way of saying let me know when you have bad news – it will not get better with time – it never does – just like cut roses.  Just tell me you have some roses for me – I will understand and appreciate the difficulty in conjuring up the courage to deliver the flowers.

There you have it.  Simple rules about how I would like to work with you on a daily, weekly, quarterly and yearly basis.  This is not difficult – but please, please try to see the world through my goggles – they are quite a different color than yours – I would really appreciate it.

Thanks, your CEO